- Aug 14, 2018
- 758
- 188
- 63
"Should I use creatine?" is the question people ask after they have already heard that it works — and it is a better question than "does it work," because the answer depends on who is asking. The research says creatine helps most people who train with heavy resistance work gain a little more strength and lean mass than they would without it. But "most people" is not "everyone," and the decision has a few honest checkpoints worth running through first.
The first checkpoint is whether you actually train in the way creatine supports. If your training is heavy sets, progressive overload, and short intense efforts, the mechanism lines up with what you do. If your training is mostly long slow cardio, the benefit shrinks toward nothing, because the energy system creatine supports is not the one doing the work. Supplements should match the training, not the other way around.
The second checkpoint is the basics. Creatine is an amplifier of work already being done, not a substitute for it. If protein intake is low, sleep is short, and the program has no progression, creatine will not fix any of that — and it is the wrong place to spend attention. The lifters who get the most from it are usually the ones who had the fundamentals handled first and added it on top.
The third checkpoint is health, and it is the one to take seriously rather than skim. The long-term studies in healthy adults are reassuring, but anyone with kidney concerns, anyone on medication affecting kidney function, and anyone with a medical condition that affects fluid balance should check with a doctor first. Forums can quote studies; they cannot look at your bloodwork.
If all three checkpoints pass — you lift heavy, your basics are solid, and there is no medical flag — then the evidence says it is a reasonable, low-cost addition with the strongest track record of any supplement on the shelf. It is still optional. Plenty of strong lifters never touch it. The question is never "should everyone," it is "should I, given how I train."
What tipped your decision one way or the other?
The first checkpoint is whether you actually train in the way creatine supports. If your training is heavy sets, progressive overload, and short intense efforts, the mechanism lines up with what you do. If your training is mostly long slow cardio, the benefit shrinks toward nothing, because the energy system creatine supports is not the one doing the work. Supplements should match the training, not the other way around.
The second checkpoint is the basics. Creatine is an amplifier of work already being done, not a substitute for it. If protein intake is low, sleep is short, and the program has no progression, creatine will not fix any of that — and it is the wrong place to spend attention. The lifters who get the most from it are usually the ones who had the fundamentals handled first and added it on top.
The third checkpoint is health, and it is the one to take seriously rather than skim. The long-term studies in healthy adults are reassuring, but anyone with kidney concerns, anyone on medication affecting kidney function, and anyone with a medical condition that affects fluid balance should check with a doctor first. Forums can quote studies; they cannot look at your bloodwork.
If all three checkpoints pass — you lift heavy, your basics are solid, and there is no medical flag — then the evidence says it is a reasonable, low-cost addition with the strongest track record of any supplement on the shelf. It is still optional. Plenty of strong lifters never touch it. The question is never "should everyone," it is "should I, given how I train."
What tipped your decision one way or the other?