What is the best exercise routine? What the question is really asking

OLYMPIC

Head Servant at NL
Staff member
Administrator
Moderator
Aug 14, 2018
703
346
63
"What is the best exercise routine?" is the most common question in fitness, and it is also the wrong question — or rather, it is three questions hiding inside one. People asking it usually mean one of three things: which routine builds the most muscle, which one is best for fat loss, or which one they will actually stick to. The honest answer is different for each, and the third version matters more than the first two combined.

If the goal is muscle, the research is fairly clear about what works: resistance training two or more times per week per muscle group, with sets taken close to failure, and progressive overload over time. The exact split — full-body, upper-lower, push-pull-legs — matters far less than most people think. Studies comparing splits find similar muscle growth when total weekly volume and effort are matched. The "best" split is mostly the one that fits your schedule and lets you train each muscle often enough with enough quality sets.

If the goal is fat loss, the routine's role is different. Fat loss comes from a sustained calorie deficit, and training's job is to preserve muscle while the deficit does its work. Resistance training is the priority, because it signals the body to keep muscle. Cardio helps by increasing energy expenditure, but it is a supporting player. A routine built around lifting, with some cardio added, beats a cardio-only routine for body composition every time.

And then there is the version of the question that actually decides results: which routine will you still be doing in six months? The best programme on paper is worthless if it demands six days a week from someone with three available, or barbell movements someone hates doing. Adherence is the bottleneck that kills more routines than any programming flaw. A simple routine done consistently for a year beats a perfect routine done for three weeks.

So the question to ask is not "what is the best routine?" but "what is the best routine for my goal, my schedule, and my preferences?" Answer those three honestly, and the routine almost picks itself.

When you picked your current routine, what mattered most — the goal, the schedule, or simply enjoying it?